As new parents, there are many things we must navigate, from late-night feedings to ensuring our baby’s well-being in the best way possible. However, one issue that is often overlooked until it arises is the pushback parents can receive from extended family when they set boundaries for their newborn. This story explores a young mother’s experience with her in-laws, as she attempted to follow medical advice and maintain her family’s safety while dealing with some unexpected tension.

The Issue at Hand: Establishing Boundaries for Baby’s Safety

It’s a rule most new parents are familiar with: no kissing the baby. Many pediatricians, for the health of the infant, advise that newborns be shielded from outside germs, especially in the early months when their immune system is still developing. For this reason, parents are typically urged to restrict contact from others, especially in the form of kissing.

In this story, a 25-year-old mother of a six-week-old daughter follows the pediatrician’s recommendation to avoid allowing anyone besides her and her husband to kiss their newborn for the first 8-12 weeks. This rule was communicated clearly to both sides of their families, and the mother felt that everyone had respected it—until one particular moment that caused a major disagreement.

Video:

The Incident: The MIL’s Surprising Reaction

The scene took place during a visit to the mother-in-law’s house. After breastfeeding her daughter, the new mother lovingly kissed her baby’s forehead before settling her to nap on her chest. At that very moment, the mother-in-law (MIL) noticed the kiss and immediately raised an eyebrow. In a passive-aggressive tone, she asked, “Oh, I’m so glad we’re allowed to kiss [baby] now! Did your pediatrician update the rules?”

Confused and surprised by the remark, the young mother explained that the pediatrician’s advice had not changed. Yet, her MIL seemed unconvinced. She accused the mother of breaking the “no kissing” rule by kissing her own baby, which sparked the beginning of a tense and heated conversation.

The Clarification: Explaining the Rules and Facing Accusations

The mother responded calmly, reiterating that the rule was always about other people not kissing the baby—not the parents themselves. However, the MIL was not easily swayed. She argued that the mother had previously said, “nobody can kiss the baby,” without specifying that it only applied to people other than the parents.

This led the mother to a breaking point, where she felt it necessary to explain the matter more firmly. “It should’ve been obvious,” she said, “the rules we told you were about what we would and wouldn’t allow OTHER PEOPLE to do.” But despite this, the MIL didn’t back down, and in a final remark, called her daughter-in-law a hypocrite.

The Apology and Request: A Shift in Tone

After some time, the MIL entered the guest room where the mother had retreated to gather herself. In what seemed like an attempt to smooth things over, the MIL apologized, claiming her earlier reaction was a kneejerk one. She confessed to being upset and confused, but now, she understood that the “no kissing” rule only applied to others.

However, there was one more thing. The MIL requested that the mother refrain from kissing the baby in front of her until she herself was allowed to do so. She admitted that watching the mother kiss the baby was upsetting, as it reminded her that she was unable to do so herself.

The mother, trying to be understanding, acknowledged that it was frustrating to have the strong urge to kiss a baby but stood her ground. “I’m not going to stop kissing my own baby for the sake of your feelings,” she responded. This, however, only seemed to escalate matters, as both the MIL and her sister-in-law (SIL) began calling the mother disrespectful and a hypocrite.

The Fallout: Tension Among the Family

Despite the apology, the situation had already created a rift. The MIL and SIL continued to criticize the mother, leading to increased tension. The young mother, trying to do what she felt was best for her baby, found herself in the midst of a family conflict that no parent wants to experience.

Medical Advice Behind the Rule: Protecting the Baby’s Health

The reason behind the mother’s firm stance was not to be difficult or controlling but was rooted in medical advice. Pediatricians, including Dr. Camile Sabella, strongly recommend that newborns avoid contact with anyone outside the immediate household for the first few months of life. The fragile immune system of an infant makes them vulnerable to even the smallest exposure to germs, which is why pediatricians advise against kissing by anyone other than the parents.

This recommendation is not a reflection of the parents’ personal preferences but a necessary precaution to protect the baby’s health. In fact, according to Dr. Sabella, grandparents should wait at least 2-3 months before kissing the baby, allowing the child’s immune system to strengthen.

Parenting Tips: Navigating Family Boundaries

This situation raises an important point: how can parents effectively communicate these boundaries with extended family, especially grandparents, who may be overly excited and eager to shower the baby with affection?

Joshua Bartlett from Natural Baby Life suggests several strategies:

• Assume the best: Most grandparents are coming from a place of love and excitement, not an attempt to undermine parental authority.
• Explain the necessity: Make it clear that the restrictions are temporary and based on the medical advice of the pediatrician, not personal preference.
• Have the conversation early: If possible, communicate these boundaries before the baby is born, so family members have time to process the request.
• Be firm but understanding: Parents should stand by their decisions while also acknowledging the emotional challenge for grandparents.

Public Opinion: Reddit Reactions to the Situation

This story, shared on Reddit, quickly gained traction, with over 10,000 upvotes. Redditors overwhelmingly supported the mother, agreeing that she was doing what was best for her baby’s health. Many pointed out that it wasn’t about disrespecting the MIL but about following medical advice.

One user humorously suggested, “What’s next? Is she going to ask you to stop breastfeeding in front of her since she doesn’t get to do it too?” Others expressed frustration at the obsession some family members have with kissing newborns, highlighting the dangers of germ transmission.

In the end, the consensus was clear: the mother was not the one at fault in this situation.

Conclusion: The Bigger Picture

In hindsight, this story highlights the delicate balance parents must maintain when setting boundaries, especially with extended family. While grandparents have a natural desire to bond with their grandchildren, it’s crucial for parents to prioritize their baby’s health and well-being. This situation serves as a reminder that respecting boundaries, even if uncomfortable, is essential for maintaining peace and ensuring the baby’s safety during the fragile early months of life.

Ultimately, the mother did what she felt was best, and while it caused some tension, it also opened up a wider conversation about family dynamics and the role of medical advice in parenting.